ARTICLE - DISPUTE RESOLUTION
Three modes of alternative dispute resolution: arbitration, adjudication @ mediation
Tan Joo Seng - updated 20 November 2026
Most construction and commercial disputes in Singapore never reach a trial. This is how I explain the three routes most clients end up on, and how I decide which one fits.
Introduction
Alternative dispute resolution (ADR) is the collective term for the ways that parties can settle a dispute short of a trial in Court, with or without the help of a third party.
Three mechanisms come up again and again in commercial and construction disputes: arbitration, mediation and adjudication. This article is a brief overview of each in Singapore, written from what I see in practice.
Arbitration
Arbitration is a consensual process. The parties agree to have their dispute decided by an arbitrator, usually through an arbitration clause in their contract. Most construction contracts have one.
The parties choose the arbitrator, and ideally that person knows the industry. A senior quantity surveyor, for example, can sit on a dispute about the value of variation works. The parties also choose the rules that govern the procedure.
Arbitrations are either institutional or ad hoc. Institutional arbitrations run under the rules of an institution such as the Singapore International Arbitration Centre (SIAC), the Singapore Institute of Arbitrators (SIArb) or the International Chamber of Commerce (ICC) International Court of Arbitration. Ad hoc arbitrations do not.
The SIAC Rules were revised with effect from 1 January 2025. For smaller claims, the Streamlined Procedure applies where the amount in dispute is up to S$1 million (or the parties agree to it). It is meant to produce a final award within three months of the tribunal being constituted. If the dispute is modest and the contract names SIAC, this is worth knowing about.
An arbitration award binds the parties and the Singapore Courts can enforce it as if it were a judgment. Because Singapore is a party to the New York Convention, awards made here are also recognised and enforceable in the other states that are party to it.
A party who is unhappy with an award has limited options. It can apply to set the award aside on narrow grounds, for example a breach of natural justice or a tribunal that exceeded its jurisdiction. In a domestic arbitration, an appeal on a question of law is also possible, but generally only with leave of the Court. The Courts do not re-hear the merits.
In mediation, the parties negotiate with the help of a neutral third party, the mediator, and try to reach a settlement themselves. Like arbitration, it depends on the parties’ agreement to take part.
Mediation can be conducted privately or under the auspices of a provider such as the Singapore Mediation Centre (SMC) or the Singapore International Mediation Centre (SIMC). Where a civil claim is already in Court, the Courts also offer court-annexed mediation. The parties may agree on a mediator; failing that, the provider appoints one.
The mediator helps the parties talk and negotiate, but cannot make a binding decision or rule on who is right. Mediations are conducted on a without prejudice basis, so what is said in mediation generally cannot be used as evidence if the mediation fails.
If the mediation succeeds, the parties record the terms in a binding settlement agreement. Since the Mediation Act 2017 came into force on 1 November 2017, a settlement reached through a designated provider or a certified mediator can, on application, be recorded as an order of Court and enforced as one. For cross-border disputes, the Singapore Convention on Mediation (in force since 12 September 2020) provides a route for enforcing international commercial settlement agreements.
Adjudication
Adjudication is a statutory process designed for one kind of dispute: payment claims under construction contracts. It comes from the Building and Construction Industry Security of Payment Act 2004 (the SOP Act), which has been in operation since 1 April 2005. Its purpose is to keep cash flowing on construction projects.
A claimant who has carried out construction work or supplied goods or services and has not been paid can serve a payment claim. If the respondent does not pay the claimed amount, the claimant can lodge an adjudication application with an authorised nominating body, currently the SMC, which appoints an adjudicator. The timelines are short and strictly applied: broadly, the adjudicator is appointed within 7 days of the application, the respondent has 7 days to respond, and the determination follows within 14 days (7 days in some cases). Payment claims also have to be served within 30 months of the work being done.
The adjudicator’s decision, the adjudication determination, is binding on an interim basis. It decides one progress payment only. Other disputes, such as defects or delay, belong in arbitration, mediation or Court, and a party can bring the underlying dispute there later.
There is no appeal to the Courts on the merits of the case. Since the 2019 amendments, either side may apply for an adjudication review by another adjudicator. The Court can set a determination aside on limited grounds such as a breach of natural justice, and the Act now sets out a non-exhaustive list of grounds. A party applying to set aside generally has to pay the unpaid adjudicated amount into Court first.
If the respondent does not pay the adjudicated amount, the claimant has several ways to enforce it. These include: obtaining leave to enforce the determination as a judgment of the Court; suspending the work; claiming direct payment from the respondent’s principal; and, in some circumstances, a lien over unfixed goods supplied.
The three side by side
ARBITRATION
ADJUDICATION
MEDIATION
Basis
Agreement of the parties
Statute (SOP Act)
Agreement of the parties
Who decides
Arbitrator(s)
Adjudicator
The parties, with help from mediator
Outcome
Final, binding award
Interim binding
Settlement agreement, if settled
Scope
Any dispute under the arbitration clause
Progress payment dispute only
Any dispute the parties choose
Speed
Moths to years, quicker under streamlined, expedited rules
Weeks, on statutory deadlines
One day, unless adjourned by agreement
Challenge
Set-aside on limited grounds
Review, then set-aside on limited grounds
Not applicable
Choosing a route
ADR deserves serious consideration as an alternative to litigation in Court. Singapore’s legal framework has moved in that direction: the Mediation Act 2017 put mediation on a statutory footing, and third-party funding, which Singapore first permitted for international arbitration in 2017, has since been extended to more kinds of proceedings.
There is no single best route. The factors I look at first are the nature of the dispute, the cost, the time it will take, and whether there is a business relationship that is worth keeping.
IN PRACTICE
A subcontractor owed money on a monthly claim usually needs cash quickly, so adjudication is the natural first step. A dispute over delay and defects on the same project often needs the fuller process of arbitration. Mediation can sit alongside either, and is often the cheapest way to settle once each side understands the other’s position.
The right choice often depends on the contract, and on steps that have to be taken early, so it is best to take proper legal advice before deciding which mode to use.